2026 Best Value Lay Ministry Schools in the Great Lakes Region

[Lay Ministry](/majors/theology-and-religious-vocations/pastoral-counseling-specialized-ministries/lay-ministry/) degree programs vary widely in price and payoff across the country. The best values balance affordable tuition against strong post-graduation earnings.
To produce this 2026 ranking, College Factual evaluated 20 schools on the balance of cost and outcomes for lay ministry students.
What’s on this page:
2026 Best Value Lay Ministry Schools in the Great Lakes Region
Below are the schools that deliver the strongest value in lay ministry, balancing cost against outcomes.
Best Value Lay Ministry Schools
Leading the list is Indiana Wesleyan University National And Global, our #1 best value for lay ministry in the Great Lakes Region. Indiana Wesleyan University National And Global is a large private not-for-profit school located in the rural area of Marion. Expect in-state tuition and fees of around $9,648. Students borrow a median of $26,338 to complete the lay ministry program here. Soon after graduation, lay ministry degree recipients from Indiana Wesleyan University National And Global generally make around $37,004. Set against $26,338 in median debt, that is a healthy payoff.
Students looking for strong value in lay ministry will find it at Grace College And Theological Seminary, which ranked #2. Set in the town of Winona Lake, Grace College And Theological Seminary is a mid-sized private not-for-profit institution. Students from in state pay about $29,645 in tuition and fees. Lay Ministry graduates carry a median of $25,500 in student loans. Soon after graduation, lay ministry degree recipients from Grace College And Theological Seminary generally make around $34,513. Set against $25,500 in median debt, that is a healthy payoff. The acceptance rate is 82%.
Students looking for strong value in lay ministry will find it at Andrews University, which ranked #3. Located in the town of Berrien Springs, Andrews University is a mid-sized private not-for-profit university. The average in-state cost of tuition and fees is $35,056. Typical student debt for lay ministry graduates is $26,314. Early-career lay ministry graduates make about $57,865. That is a strong return on a $26,314 median debt. Roughly 82% of applicants are accepted.
Students looking for strong value in lay ministry will find it at Bethel College Mishawaka, which ranked #4. Bethel College Mishawaka is a small private not-for-profit school located in the city of Mishawaka. In-state tuition and fees average $34,600. Typical student debt for lay ministry graduates is $23,319. Early-career lay ministry graduates make about $31,046. Set against $23,319 in median debt, that is a healthy payoff. Bethel College Mishawaka admits about 98% of applicants.
Grace Bible College came in at #5 on our 2026 list of the best value lay ministry schools. Set in the city of Wyoming, Grace Bible College is a small private not-for-profit institution. Students from in state pay about $17,190 in tuition and fees. Students borrow a median of $30,118 to complete the lay ministry program here. Lay Ministry graduates of Grace Bible College earn a median of $41,219 early in their careers. Set against $30,118 in median debt, that is a healthy payoff. The acceptance rate is 99%.
Calvin College ranked #6 on our 2026 list of the best value lay ministry schools. Set in the city of Grand Rapids, Calvin College is a mid-sized private not-for-profit institution. Expect in-state tuition and fees of around $39,350. Typical student debt for lay ministry graduates is $22,707. Lay Ministry graduates of Calvin College earn a median of $44,220 early in their careers. Set against $22,707 in median debt, that is a healthy payoff. The acceptance rate is 71%.
Narrow Lay Ministry Schools by State
More Lay Ministry Rankings
View All Lay Ministry Rankings >
Notes and References
This ranking is produced by College Factual (MF_RANKING_2025), 2026 edition. Schools are scored on the balance of cost (tuition and student debt) against student outcomes (post-graduation earnings) — a measure of return on investment, drawn primarily from the U.S. Department of Education (IPEDS and College Scorecard).
Ranking method: College Major Best Value · 20 schools evaluated.
*Averages shown above reflect the top 2 ranked schools only.
- The Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS) from the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES), a branch of the U.S. Department of Education (DOE), serves as the core of our data about colleges.
- Some other college data, including much of the graduate earnings data, comes from the U.S. Department of Education’s (College Scorecard).
More about our data sources and methodologies.